• Opinion
• Petitioner's Initial Brief on the Merits
• Respondent's Brief on the Merit
• Petitioner's Reply Brief on the Merits
• Petitioner's Supplemental Initial brief on the Merits
• Respondent's Supplental Answer Brief on the Merits
• Petitioner's Supplenental Reply Brief on the Merits

Oral Argument

Oral Argument

RealVideo or Windows Media must be installed on your computer to view the oral argument. Gavel to Gavel is produced by WFSU-TV.